Men Without Women ~ Haruki Murakami

Murakami’s construct leaves all of his stories open to a myriad interpretations, and that’s the beauty of his narrative. He manages to etch distinct characters in each of his tales with remarkable dexterity and the Murakami mind observes quietly, much like the Lamprey, who live off life itself. I was agog by the sheer brilliance of an imagination that defies coherence yet draws you in, makes you believe.
Book Cover of Men without Women by Murakami

Seven spectacular short stories by a master storyteller that dazzle and baffle and make us sit up and wonder, showcasing a wide range of characters from bartenders, lovers, wives, actors etc. No story leaves you without questions- mostly existential, some more material, but Murakami, with his exquisite penmanship does it again. His signature wry humour lines every tale, as his defining style. I love how it seeps through the most earnest of his stories.

Quote - murakami

Talking of Murakami would be like trying to dip a toe in the ocean and seeking out that one elusive shell with a particular shape, with no success. I tried and failed.
So suffice it to say that each story from Men Without Women has something to offer to that which lies concealed, and it’s up to us, the reader, to seize an opportunity and unravel before it passes us by. 

In – Sheherazade, the eel-like Lamprey, symbolic of a being in the world who exists, yet invisible – absorbs all that needs absorption. Sheherazade is a parasitical being that hides in broad daylight. Lovesickness is presented as an actual medical condition. 

One’s imagination ignites.

The story of the Man whose wife cheats on him- Kino:  the character who sat upon the bar stool- was he not just an extension of him, watching day after day his own self? Not a mirror image, but a separate being that has found a cosy seat outside of him? Uncanny. Believable?

A bar stool

Who asks him to leave and find salvation- was it not he himself, who shows him that being a silent observer and then going for the kill, is possible without being muscular and menacing outwardly? The snakes…egging him on to reach within, and confront his pain, only to be expunged;  were these coiling creatures there for real after all?
When his grief ultimately catches up with him, Murakami leaves us with this oppressive thought, knocks that drown you. I heard them.

Murakami’s construct leaves all of his stories open to a myriad interpretations, and that’s the beauty of his narrative. 
He manages to etch distinct characters in each of his tales with remarkable dexterity and the Murakami mind observes quietly, much like the Lamprey, who live off life itself. I was agog by the sheer brilliance of an imagination that defies coherence yet draws you in, makes you believe.

Samsa in Love, borrowed from Kafka’s character- Gregor Samsa, in a reversal of the original story ‘The Metamorphosis’, presents a locked-up boy- what an image cast! I struggled to grasp the mystique that shrouds yet grips you from the start. Who was he- a man-child locked up because he is ‘differently-abled’, a prisoner of war, a family skeleton, what? Eery yet undefinably magnetic. When the hunchback attracts him, suddenly he’s lovestruck…you baulk! This particular story is woven in knots, and puzzles, impossible to unravel. 

Even as you are glued, you detach, but with caution, and that is what ensues with many of his tales.

Favourites remain- Drive my Car and An Independent Organ. I resonated most with them, deftly conjuring up the characters in real time, moving with them, listening in, a fly on the wall. They communicated, albeit with a halting start, not just with each other, but with me.

Many of Murakami’s characters are trying to reinvent themselves. Is it possible to, is the question that plagued me.

In AIO – Tokai– the guy has multiple affairs, ostensibly without emotional leverage, much like an animal in season. Yet it is he who ends up giving up his heart to the very woman to whom he is but a means to an end; Nature’s way of payback.

picture of am empty chair in the balcony

Before you begin to read a Murakami, novel or short form, hold your breath, because the ride is surely going to blaze a trail and force you to take stock of your own life and of those around you. For a while, a meditative spirit gets hold of you- and you are left wondering about the realness of things, and whether life, as we understand it, is a mere illusion. Yes, Haruki Murakami seems to do that to me. Shaking off this unnamable sentiment becomes a task in itself once you turn the last page and shut the book reluctantly. 

@kamalininatesan 2018

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like:

The Firebird ~ Saikat Majumdar

The Firebird ~ Saikat Majumdar

Majumdar writes with great sensitivity- delving deep into the young lad’s mind, drawing from both the light and the dark that exist in tandem within. Ori senses the resentment his mother’s stage life provokes in others around him, the family and neighbours.

My Book

Connect With Me

Popular Posts

The Firebird ~ Saikat Majumdar

The Firebird ~ Saikat Majumdar

Majumdar writes with great sensitivity- delving deep into the young lad’s mind, drawing from both the light and the dark that exist in tandem within. Ori senses the resentment his mother’s stage life provokes in others around him, the family and neighbours.

Script & ScreenWriting Workshop (HWR) May 2023

Script & ScreenWriting Workshop (HWR) May 2023

A script and screenwriting workshop in a haven called Himalayan Writer’s Retreat nestled in the mountains at Satkhol (3 hours from the plains at Kathgodam) en route via Bhimtal. It was an enriching experience with participants from all over India and abroad. Anu Singh Choudhary who has co-scripted many screenplays such as Aryaa, mentored us with great patience and panache. The four-day workshop was a great learning experience. And in such an idyllic environment too.

Share This